This is a pretty common question because a lot of times people don’t care that much about the printer they are getting, they only care about how much it’s going to cost them in the long run. Some people use their inkjets just for documents and very rarely print pictures, and for people like that it doesn’t matter what the printer resolution is or how big the LCD or any of that jazz.
Well the answer to this is: there is no answer. There is no one printer that stands above all others in terms of its ink costs. Now before you get too angry for that big tease…there are certain things you can look for to find the models with the cheapest ink costs.
- Look for printers with individual ink cartridges
- Look for printers with photo specific cartridges
- Do not buy a Lexmark/Dell
- Only buy an HP if you plan on refilling
Canon and Epson are the main ones for individual ink cartridges, although HP has introduced a few models in the last year or so that feature individual cartridges. Printers with separate cartridges for photo colors help you save your regular colors for when you are doing color printing you don’t care about. You will never save on ink with a Lexmark or a Dell printer, so don’t even try. Finally, as we have mentioned before, HP cartridges keep getting smaller and smaller, to the point where their ink costs twice as much ($3.60/ml vs. $1.85/ml) as it did just a few years ago. At the same time, you can save a lot of money with HPs by refilling the cartridges, so operating them is either pretty expensive or really cheap.
The short answer to this is probably to just buy a Canon, because they have individual ink cartridges that are usually cheaper than all other manufacturers, and most cost per page test results (like this one, for example) favor Canon printers.
19 Comments about “Which Printer Has the Cheapest Ink?”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.









October 2nd, 2006 at 8:43 pm
Good article with good info. However, I wanted to add Brother printer to the consideration since it also has separate ink cartridges.
Thomas
October 4th, 2006 at 8:35 am
Well, this makes me feel good about having just bought a Canon Pixma MP530. Nothing to report yet, it hasn’t even been plugged in, but I wanted to say that the reasons I bought it were: features for the price, individual ink tanks, and reliability. This is replacing a Canon BJC-85 portable printer that absolutely refuses to quit! This poor printer has been through hell boucing around in an RV for a few years, and performs like a champ. I’m actually a little anxious to replace it, because it’s the one piece of equipment in my home office that always works, but it’s time.
October 4th, 2006 at 8:52 am
Canon seems to have always made reliable inkjet printers. I remember their bubble jet printers from several years back. Those things may not have had really good print quality, but they kept going and going and going for years and years.
October 4th, 2006 at 8:56 am
Canon Pixma 4000 hands down the economic winner, proven to be slightly under $.03 per page.
HP’s are middle of road.
Certain Epson stylus printers are more expensive that dating Paris Hilton, yes even more expensive than Lexmark.
October 4th, 2006 at 9:21 am
Now you tell me!
I’ve had some luck with refilling HP cartridges.. can get messy… but… it’s worth it. As long as they work.
I’m curious.. how about comparing cost per page with laser color printers vs inkjet… and refilling laser cartridges vs buying new.
Great article… thanks for the info.
October 4th, 2006 at 9:43 am
Be careful if you intend to reduce your HP printing costs by using after-market cartridges OR if you intend to REFILL your HP cartridges!!!
The print-heads on HP printers seem to wear out 5x faster when using either after-market cartridges or refilled cartridges. If you haven’t priced them yet, they are expensive. You might have a two-cartridge HP printer, but my guess is that you’ll have three color print-heads to replace, PLUS your Black print-head to replace. Each will cost you about $25, so figure on $100 when replacing the entire set of print-heads.
October 4th, 2006 at 12:28 pm
Valuable info. I like the truthful comment about Dell and Lexmark. I found this out the hard way with Lexmark. I could almost buy a new printer for what two replacement cartridges cost. So I did - but not a Lexmark.
October 4th, 2006 at 12:41 pm
Help here please, why should I buy an Epson instead an HP.
which ink is more economic.
ben
October 4th, 2006 at 1:13 pm
My computer consultant advised me to get rid of a Canon MP 730 that was not working, but I ordered a ne print head and it now works just fine. It was a lot cheaper than replacing this machine.
October 4th, 2006 at 4:28 pm
Somebody needs to look at the ink cartridges
for the Epson C60…the black ink for less than $10 makes this printer a great deal..
October 4th, 2006 at 8:19 pm
I buy and use as many epson 740 printers I can find on craigs list for home and school. WOW great prints and CHEAP INK fronm one dollar a cartridge to 7.99 on line with pacific ink.
So do any readers want to ditch an old , working 740? I am a teacher in a high school and my students print alot!
Ellen
October 6th, 2006 at 6:47 am
I need one or two black ink M4640 refills for my Dell 962 Printer. Please give me buying terms
as I have some empty cartridges if they can be
sent in for refills. The Dell direct prices on
their refills seem pretty high. Thanks, Van
October 7th, 2006 at 7:36 am
I have a brother multi & it’s given outstanding service and the ink is rather cheap… unlike the canon which would dry up and require a total ink unit replacement at $50. A reconditioned brother cost less than ink for the canon….
October 10th, 2006 at 2:46 pm
I have a canon BJC 250 and a Lexmark Z 12. Both use individual cartridges. I refill both black and color cartridges for both printers.
Both printers are several years old and have never missed a beat.
January 5th, 2007 at 8:51 am
I happen to have hated my Canon… and I’ll only buy HP from now on. I owned my first HP Printer for 10 years when it finally died after a paper jam (of all things). I neglectfully let it go and bought another. I was very surprised that the size of the cartriges (92/93), however, had shrunk CONSIDERABLY at nearly the same cost as my old cartridges (23/45). If I remember correctly the 45 cartridge was 1.42 oz. and the new one is only 5 ml!! That’s outrageous… so, I refill them myself… thank you very much!
Thanks for this forum! It was enlightening.
November 29th, 2007 at 7:20 am
Noone mentined that the printers which do have permanent print heads, (not replaceable with ink as HP) may need head replacement -or displacement- if you do not use them often.
Canon- Epson may be cheaper in consumables but you have to use frequently, or at least you cannot neglect them.
May 6th, 2008 at 4:41 pm
Try looking at the Sharp 5100. The black ink cartridge is $9.95 and it prints twice as much. I have had one for 4 monts and it’g great. I even found ink cartridges online for $4.95 on idproducts.com. Check it out. I also use a x4270 Lexmark that I have been filling the ink cartridges for 3 years. The cartridges are good for about 15 refills!
June 14th, 2008 at 12:17 pm
I am so happy to have found this site after searching through vendors sites and still not getting the information I needed! I am going to take many of the suggestions here to help me decide on a new printer. After paying WAY too much for ink for so long I really need something economical. Thanks again!
June 29th, 2008 at 8:22 pm
WOW! This is great info! It must all be true since it is here in writing. I will run right out and get a Canon to blow my head off.